Dark and Darker
IRONMACE · Shooter, RPG, Dungeon Crawler
Overview
An unforgiving hardcore fantasy FPS dungeon PvPvE adventure. Band together with your friends and use your courage, wits, and cunning to uncover mythical treasures, defeat gruesome monsters, while staying one step ahead of the other devious treasure-hunters.
Read moreShow less
An Unforgiving Hardcore First-Person Fantasy Dungeon Adventure.
Unfathomable fortunes await the brave and the foolish willing to delve into the devastated depths of an ancient citadel. Band together with your friends and use your courage, wits, and cunning to uncover mythical treasures, defeat gruesome monsters, while staying one step ahead of the other devious treasure-hunters. Once you’ve plundered your riches, now comes the hard part, getting out alive. Find the hidden escape routes before the ever-expanding darkness reclaims your riches and your corpse to her irresistible hoard.
Irresistibly Classic
Dark and Darker aims to capture the wonder and awe of classic fantasy adventure games. We stand on the shoulders of giants and strive to pay respects to the traditions of the genre. We hearken back to the old worlds where danger lurks around each corner, but where courage and adventure are rewarded with untold riches.
Choose a role, party up!
Team up with friends and assemble a party to increase your chances of survival. Choose from a wide array of timeless fantasy roles and build the perfect three-person squad. Play as a brawny barbarian holding the frontlines while your sharp-eyed ranger friend fires arrows from afar and your merry bard sustains morale with a lively tune.
Unforgivingly Hardcore
Dark and Darker is a world of high risks and high returns. Explore a mystical underground fortress where the dangers are unrelenting and even the smallest misstep can result in death. Sound judgement reaps huge rewards, but death carries a heavy penalty with the loss of all your loot.
A focus on First-Person Combat
Dark and Darker strives for high immersion. Adventurers must use their eyes and ears like you would in the real world. Players must target, track, and aim against the countless challenges they encounter. We supply a wide array of close combat weapons that each have unique patterns to learn and master. Strikes to the head and back do critical damage. Knowing how to properly wield each weapon gives the player an edge to survive in this harsh world.
Old Magic
Magic is a powerful but unwieldy force in the world of Dark and Darker. Mastery requires long incantations, special skills, the right channeling equipment, and a tactical eye. Spells must be timed and aimed for maximum effect. For the magically uninclined, tinkering, knowledge of special equipment, and a little foresight can help level the field.
Comfort in the Shadows
The darkness is your friend in this unrelenting setting. Turn off lights and use the darkness to hide from foes or set up ambushes. If the tides of battles take a turn for the worse, blending into the darkness can lead to a stealthy retreat.
Escape!
Discover hidden portals to delve deeper and deeper underground and uncover the most hideous monsters and invaluable artifacts. All the riches you collect are for naught if you can’t make it out alive. Find a rare exit before the dark swarm comes to collect your soul.
From the game's Steam store page.
THE GAMEQ VERDICT9,999 reviews analyzed
What players are actually saying
1. Summary
Players who like Dark and Darker say they cannot find it anywhere else: a first-person, Dungeons and Dragons style dungeon crawl where every run puts your gear at risk, another team could be behind any door, and torchlight and footsteps carry the tension. Some negative reviews call it one of their favorite games, or say it used to be. What drives them away is how often the game changes under them. According to reviewers, the Season 11 update in October 2026 removed the PvE Adventure mode, merged solo and duo queues into trio lobbies, took away map choice and brought back battle royale style mechanics, and the reviews written in the weeks after it were almost all negative. Long-time players see it as one more swing in a cycle of features being added, reverted and restored.
Class balance (one-shots, ranged builds, gear gaps) is the other large complaint, followed by bugs and performance, cheaters and real-money traders, and a hardware check that locks some players out of High Roller. Opinion is divided on the free version and paid Legendary Status, on how punishing the game should be, and on whether new players can find a way in. Even Season 11 has defenders: a small group welcomed it as a return to the hardcore original, though over half of the longer reviews from those weeks name the update or the modes it removed.
2. What keeps coming up
What players praise
A dungeon crawl fans call uniqueHigh
14% of the longer reviews describe the game as unique, addictive, a blast or a favorite, in thumbs-up and thumbs-down reviews alike. What they single out is the mix of fantasy classes, monsters and bosses, loot you can lose, and other players hunting in the same dungeon. "The combat system is unlike anything else out there and the skill in it can only come from playing the game," one player wrote. Several describe it as Tarkov or Arc Raiders with swords and say nothing else fills that niche. Negative reviews often grant this before explaining why they left.
Atmosphere, sound and tensionMedium
Positive reviews account for most of the praise for the dark corridors, the sound design and the constant sense of threat. One player listed "The flickering torchlight, the sound of plate armor clanking in a silent hallway, and the constant dread of another team lurking in the shadows." Another wrote: "Sound design and atmosphere are top notch the fact that other players are looming adds a suspense but at the same time frustration." Footsteps and darkness are also mechanics: rogues hide in unlit corners, and players listen for teams before committing to a fight.
Playing with friendsLow
5% of the longer reviews mention friends. One player who stayed away for years because of the negative reviews found "a pretty damn fun game solo or with friends or even randos." Others treat a group as a requirement, because without two regular teammates the trio-focused lobbies feel stacked against you (see the solo play item below).
Where players are split
The free version, Legendary Status and the cash shopHigh
13% of the longer reviews bring up the free version, the paid Legendary Status upgrade, races or cosmetics. To some the free tier is a fair trial: "Think of the free version as a demo, outside of that cheeky marketing the game is amazing." Others call it a paywall, pointing to what reviewers describe as a single character slot, a gear cap and locked content: "do not play unless u want your loot blocked behind a paywall." A smaller group calls the paid races and skins pay-to-win, and some complain about cosmetic prices and the season pass. After Season 11, players who had paid said the modes they bought it for were gone: "I initially supported this game and bought the Legendary Status upgrade, but the latest direction taken by the development team makes it impossible to recommend."
Learning curve and the new-player experienceHigh
13% of the longer reviews talk about new players, tutorials or the learning curve. Supporters say the depth is the point and the curve is worth climbing. Critics describe spawning in, getting killed by geared veterans and having no safe place to learn: "only good if you have squads to play with being a new player couldn't even finish one game every other player killed me immediately." Before Season 11, several positive reviews credited the PvE Adventure mode and low-gear lobbies with making the game easier to start. After it, reviewers said those on-ramps were gone, one listing "Removed PvE mode so new players cant even learn the game and on top of it the unified queue means they get to play against a full trio party."
Melee combat feelMedium
Combat comes up in 9% of the longer reviews. Fans like how much skill it rewards: spacing, ducking under swings, blocking and weapon hitboxes. A smaller group calls it clunky, citing blocks that fail to register and stiff movement, and one player found that whether a swing lands depends on the frame rate.
How hardcore it should beMedium
7% of the longer reviews argue about difficulty in terms like hardcore, easy mode or skill issue, and this is where Season 11 finds its defenders. They welcome faster, more decisive fights and higher stakes: "now everything you do matters a lot more. more incentives to search for gear. and since fights are more decisive and faster now, it's not Run and Runner anymore." Another wrote: "It feels like im finally back in the playtest where the game is more hardcore." Critics answer that the punishment now falls on casual and solo players, and that monsters as well as players can drop you in a hit or two.
What frustrates players
Season 11 and the cycle of reversalsHigh
30% of the longer reviews talk about Season 11, the removed modes or the game's habit of reverting changes, and among the longer reviews written from October 5, 2026, 52% name Season 11 or the removed PvE, solo or duo modes. Reviewers list what they say Season 11 changed: the PvE Adventure mode and Squire Royale removed, solo and duo queues merged into a single trio lobby, map choice replaced by random dungeons, fog of war and a closing zone added, health pools lowered and the damage reduction cap lifted. Players who came for the modes put it bluntly: "Bought this for the PvE and they removed it." Long-time players see a pattern, describing earlier rounds in which solo queues, PvE and map selection were removed, restored after a good stretch of seasons, and then removed again. "It's a constant series of seeing good updates and then getting Rug-Pulled because someone else said otherwise," one wrote. Reviewers link these swings to changes in who leads design, and some say they would come back if the modes did.
Class balance, one-shots and gear gapsHigh
25% of the longer reviews discuss balance, the meta, nerfs and buffs, one-shots or gear disparity. The details change from season to season, but the complaint usually runs the same way: one or two classes dominate, ranged and spellcaster builds kill before melee can close the gap, and well-geared players or teams can't be beaten. "This game keeps moving toward a rat meta instead of a real dungeon PvP game," one player wrote, describing High Roller lobbies full of rogues and wizards who avoid fights. After Season 11 the complaints turned to arrows that kill in two hits, monsters that hit as hard as players, and gear gaps that, reviewers said, leave no chance against geared premades. Players with hundreds of hours raise balance far more often than newcomers do.
Bugs, crashes and performanceMedium
10% of the longer reviews mention bugs, crashes, lag, disconnects or poor optimization. Players report frame drops in full lobbies on capable hardware ("sometimes the fps drop lower than 60 even while keeping everything at low"), crashes mid-raid that cost gear, server lag when looting, and disconnects in the lobby. After Season 11, one player said the custom game mode offered in place of PvE crashed within minutes. On the other side, one positive review from mid-2026 credits recent updates with better stability and bug fixes.
Cheaters, teamers and real-money tradersMedium
8% of the longer reviews describe cheaters, cross-teaming or real-money trading. "The hacking has gotten so bad, the game is basically unplayable whenever there's other players involved," one wrote. Others point to gold sellers, banned cheaters returning on new accounts, and teams cooperating against other players, and a couple of reviewers warn Oceania players in particular. A couple of others say they have not run into cheaters.
Anti-cheat and the High Roller hardware checkMedium
6% of the longer reviews object to the anti-cheat or to the requirement, which reviewers say arrived with a patch, of TPM 2.0, Secure Boot and HVCI for High Roller lobbies. Reviewers say that locks out older PCs, Linux and Steam Deck: "Secure boot and TPM 2.0 is not possible for me to turn on as I am playing on Linux." A few had paid for Legendary Status and say they can no longer play the content they paid for. Others dislike the kernel-level anti-cheat itself, and one warns that it stays on the PC after the game is uninstalled.
Playing solo or in a duoMedium
5% of the longer reviews describe solo or duo players facing full teams, 1v3 fights and premades. Before Season 11, this was why players valued the separate solo and duo queues. With the queues merged, it became a pressing problem for anyone without two regular teammates. "If you don't have friends to play with who can tough it out, GL," wrote one player, warning that geared premades will overwhelm you.
Player count worriesLow
4% of the longer reviews talk about a dying game, player counts or players leaving. Some say each disruptive change drives more people away, while one Season 11 defender said the new update put players in every match.
Bans and reportsLow
2% of the longer reviews describe being banned unfairly, often after being reported for stream sniping, with no explanation or appeal: "And there is no way to appeal a season ban so you're just out."
Seasonal wipesLow
A handful of reviews say regular progress wipes sap the motivation of long-term players: "the forced wipes are becoming exhausting." One asks for an optional prestige system in their place.
3. The player conversation
13% of the longer reviews carry edit markers, and some read as a diary of the game: thumbs up when a season went well, thumbs down when the next patch reversed it, and back again. Some veterans count time played on the studio's own Blacksmith launcher before the game came to Steam.
What players write about depends on how long they have played. Those with under 10 hours bring up the learning curve more often than any other group, and the limits of the free version more often than veterans do. Reviewers with 500 or more hours write most about balance and the design reversals. Cheating and technical problems come up at similar rates at every playtime.
Season 11 changed the tone abruptly. Reviews written before October 5, 2026 were close to even, with many recommending the game while listing caveats about balance, bugs and cheaters. Reviews written in the following weeks were 5% positive and dwelt on the removed modes. Of the few recommending the game in those weeks, several praised the harder, faster fights, and several dismissed the negative wave as review bombing by players upset that the game got harder.
4. What the developers could do
- Bring back solo and duo queues and a PvE mode with real progression. Over half of the longer reviews written after Season 11 name the update or the removed PvE, solo and duo modes, and some say they would return if the modes came back.
- Commit to a stable design direction and test big changes before they ship. Long-time players describe a repeated cycle of features removed, restored and removed again, and one complains that big changes went straight to the live servers instead of the test servers.
- Rebalance one-shots, ranged dominance and gear disparity. A quarter of the longer reviews discuss balance, and after Season 11 the complaints turned to two-hit arrows, harder-hitting monsters and geared premades that new and solo players say they cannot fight.
- Give new players a safe place to learn. Reviewers ask for a real tutorial, a practice area or low-gear lobbies, and say PvE mode was the on-ramp that Season 11 removed.
- Fix crashes, disconnects and frame drops. Players report frame drops in full lobbies, crashes that cost gear mid-raid, lobby disconnects and, in one Season 11 review, a custom game mode that crashed within minutes.
- Step up enforcement against cheaters, teamers and gold sellers. Players describe banned cheaters returning on fresh accounts and cross-teaming going unpunished, and a couple single out Oceania.
- Offer a path into High Roller for players who cannot enable TPM 2.0 or Secure Boot, and announce such requirements well ahead. Linux, Steam Deck and older-PC owners say they lost access to High Roller, some after paying for Legendary Status.
- Add a review and appeal process for report-based bans. Players describe instant season bans after stream-sniping reports with no evidence shown and no way to appeal.
